Kitchen Know-How
For a jacket potato with a crisp skin and a fluffy middle, buy a floury variety: Maris Piper or King Edward are the safe choices for a jacket or baked potato, and a supermarket bag labelled “baking potatoes” is the sensible budget buy. Choose large, evenly sized potatoes, bake them at 200°C (180°C fan, gas 6) for an hour to an hour and twenty minutes, and leave the foil in the drawer.
The short answer
- Best all-round buy: Maris Piper. Dry, floury flesh, and widely sold by name.
- The classic: King Edward. Floury, and the variety Waitrose and Sainsbury’s Magazine both name for jackets.
- Best value: an own-label bag marked “baking potatoes”. The variety is rarely named, but the label exists to tell you it bakes well.
- For flavour: Vivaldi. It topped a Gardeners’ World tasting trial of ten baking varieties.
- Avoid: anything sold as salad, baby or new potatoes. Waxy flesh bakes dense and moist, not fluffy.
- Short of time: start them in the microwave and finish in a hot oven, or use the air fryer. Timings are in the table below.
The best potatoes for jacket potatoes
Jacket potatoes have the dullest shopping list in British cooking: one ingredient. Which makes it irritating that the bag so often won’t tell you what that ingredient is. Here are the varieties you are most likely to find in a UK supermarket or farm shop, with what the people who grow, test and sell them actually say.
| Variety | Texture when baked | Our verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Maris Piper | Dry and floury | The default. Jamie Oliver’s team says it is “often considered the gold standard” for jackets in the UK, and it is widely sold by name. |
| King Edward | Floury | The traditional choice, a heritage variety dating from 1902. Waitrose names it first for jackets; Sainsbury’s Magazine calls it “great for baked jackets”. |
| “Baking potatoes” (own label) | Usually floury | The value buy. The variety changes through the year, but these bags are sold specifically for baking. |
| Vivaldi | Creamy, buttery | The flavour pick. It won the Gardeners’ World trial on taste, and Sainsbury’s sells it as a named baking potato. |
| Rooster | All-rounder, red skin | A good one if it’s what you have. The AHDB variety database calls it “an excellent all-round potato”. |
| Marfona | Smooth skin; not sold as floury | Grown for size. It is a popular supermarket baker, but the Gardeners’ World tasters found it bland. |
| Cara | Soft and moist | Smooth and round, but moister than a floury jacket wants to be. |
| Russet | Dry and mealy | The standard North American potato, widely sold there for baking. If a US recipe asks for one, use Maris Piper or King Edward. |
Maris Piper: the default
If you buy one named variety for jackets, make it this one. Great British Chefs describes Maris Piper as “dry and floury” and lists baking among its uses, and it is widely sold by name, so it is the easiest variety to ask for and get.
King Edward: the traditionalist’s choice
King Edward dates from 1902, when a variety called Fellside Hero was renamed for the coronation of Edward VII, according to Ripon Museums. It is floury, and Great British Chefs calls it “best suited to roasting, baking or chipping”. Waitrose’s jacket potato guide names it first, as does Sainsbury’s Magazine. Its pale skin is marked with pink, which makes it easy to spot in a loose display. There is little to choose between it and Maris Piper in a jacket; buy whichever looks better on the day.
One caveat for gardeners. In the Gardeners’ World trial, home-grown King Edwards produced no tubers large enough to count as jacket-sized. That finding is about growing them. In a shop, you can pick out large ones by eye.
“Baking potatoes”: what’s actually in the bag
Most supermarket baking-potato bags don’t name the variety. Tesco’s own-label bag, for instance, says only that the potatoes are “carefully chosen throughout the year”. That is less evasive than it sounds: the variety can change through the year, and the label tells you the potatoes have been selected for baking. Jamie Oliver’s team calls these bags “almost always a floury variety” and a reliable choice, though that is a generalisation rather than a guarantee.
Not every baker is a floury Maris Piper. The AHDB variety database describes Marfona as a “very popular early baker for numerous supermarket outlets”, and notes that it tends to produce a large proportion of baker-sized potatoes. So an unnamed baking bag is not necessarily Maris Piper. For a weeknight supper that hardly matters, and the own-label bag is the sensible buy.
Vivaldi: the one that won the taste test
In a trial published in 2019, Gardeners’ World Magazine grew and baked ten varieties to find the best jacket potato. Vivaldi came first, scoring ten out of ten on taste, with tasters praising its “great flavour, creamy texture and delicious skin”. Sainsbury’s sells Vivaldi as a named baking potato in its Taste the Difference range. Sainsbury’s describes it as having a “rich and buttery flavour”, which matches what the trial tasters found. Bear in mind that the trial potatoes were home-grown.
Rooster, Marfona and Cara
Rooster, with its red skin and yellow flesh, is a good all-rounder. Albert Bartlett, which sells Roosters under its own name, says their “uniform, rounded shape and size” means they “also make great jacket potatoes”. Marfona gave Gardeners’ World a very high proportion of jacket-sized, smooth, evenly shaped potatoes, and the AHDB calls it a popular baker with supermarkets. The Gardeners’ World tasting panel, though, called it “bland” and found the skin “not crispy”. Cara is sold in seed catalogues for boiling and baking, but DT Brown, for one, calls it waxy and describes its flesh as “soft, moist”. That is fine under a ladle of chilli, less so if you are after the dry, fluffy crumb.
What about russet potatoes?
Russet Burbank, with its dark brown skin, is the standard potato in North America and the one widely sold there for baking, with flesh that is “white, dry, and mealy”. That is exactly what you want in a jacket. When an American recipe calls for a russet, use a floury British variety such as Maris Piper or King Edward instead.
For the full picture of which British varieties are floury, waxy or somewhere between, see our guide to UK potato varieties.
Why a floury potato makes the best jacket
It comes down to dry matter: how much of the potato is solids rather than water. Potato scientists put it plainly. Potatoes with high dry matter and low moisture are “mealy, ideal for baking”. Those with low dry matter and more moisture are waxy and better for boiling. In the oven, a high-dry-matter potato bakes to the dry, crumbly flesh the trade calls “mealy”, which is the texture you want under a pat of butter. A waxy potato baked whole stays dense and slightly wet.
The difference is real enough to taste. In a 1967 study in the American Potato Journal, sensory panels ranked baked potatoes for mealiness, and their rankings tracked the potatoes’ measured specific gravity and total solids (in other words, their dry matter). The smallest difference the panels could reliably detect was about one gram of solids per hundred grams of cooked potato. This is one reason the variety matters so much in a jacket: there is nothing else in the dish to hide behind.
Pay for the name when you want certainty about the variety; buy the own-label bag when you want supper.
How to choose jacket potatoes in the shop
- Buy them matched. Potatoes of a similar size finish at the same time. Waitrose picks its Essential Large Potatoes for jackets for exactly this reason. Buying loose lets you match the potatoes by eye, or on the scale at the end of the aisle.
- Know your size. The oven times below are for a typical large baking potato, the kind sold in a baking-potato pack. A much bigger potato will need longer, so test it rather than trusting the clock.
- Look for a regular shape and smooth skin. Great British Chefs says Osprey is “particularly good when baked thanks to their smooth skin”, and the same logic applies when you pick from a loose display.
- Check them over. Pass on any that are soft, sprouting or tinged with green.
- Store them sensibly. Keep them in a cool, dark place. The Food Standards Agency now says the fridge is fine too: its older warning against refrigerating raw potatoes has been withdrawn.
A word on cost. Paying extra for a named variety buys you certainty about what you are getting. It does not guarantee a better supper than the own-label baking bag beside it. A jacket potato is a cheap supper, and it needn’t become an expensive one.
How long to cook a jacket potato in the oven
At 200°C (180°C fan, gas 6), a large jacket potato takes an hour to an hour and twenty minutes; at 220°C (gas 7), allow about an hour for an average-sized one. This is the classic method, and the sources we checked agree on the essentials.
- Heat the oven to 200°C (180°C fan, gas 6).
- Scrub and dry the potatoes thoroughly. Gardeners’ World advises drying them well after washing.
- Prick each potato several times with a fork so steam can escape.
- Rub with a little oil and plenty of salt. Waitrose suggests salting the skins while they are still slightly damp.
- Bake directly on the oven shelf, not in a dish.
- Test after an hour. Squeeze gently in a tea towel, or push in a skewer. The potato is done when it gives easily all the way through. A large one may need another 10–15 minutes.
Skip the foil. Wrapping a potato holds in moisture, when the aim is to dry and crisp the skin as it cooks. olive magazine makes the point. Helen Carey, quoted in Waitrose’s guide, goes a step further and bakes the potatoes on a bed of rock salt, which she says absorbs moisture and makes the potato fluffier. And on colour, the Food Standards Agency advises baking starchy foods to “a golden yellow colour or lighter” to limit acrylamide. A crisp, golden skin is the aim, not a dark brown one.
Faster: the microwave start and the air fryer
An hour in the oven is fine on a Saturday. It is less fine at six on a Tuesday, with swimming to collect. There are two honest shortcuts.
Microwave, then oven. Waitrose’s quick method: prick the potatoes, microwave on high (900W) for 3 minutes, turn, give them another 3 minutes, then brush with oil, season and finish in the oven at 220°C for 20 minutes. olive magazine is blunter: it says the microwave start creates so much moisture that the skin “will never properly crisp up”. Expect a softer jacket, then, but one ready half an hour or more sooner.
The air fryer. Prick, oil and salt the potato as for the oven, then cook at 200°C for about 45 minutes, turning halfway, which is ProCook’s method. Air fryers vary in power and basket size, so treat 45 minutes as a starting point and check with a skewer.
Microwave only. It works if speed is all that matters. Tesco’s pack instructions give 6 minutes at 900W (7 minutes at 800W) for one potato, turned halfway, then 2 minutes standing. Expect a soft skin.
| Method | Setting | Time (one large baker) | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Oven, classic | 200°C / 180°C fan / gas 6 | 1 hr–1 hr 20 min | Tesco pack (60–80 min); olive magazine (1 hr, plus 10–15 min if needed) |
| Oven, hotter | 220°C / gas 7 | About 1 hr (average-sized) | Waitrose |
| Oven, Gardeners’ World trial | 190°C | 1 hr 45 min–2 hr | Gardeners’ World |
| Microwave, then oven | 900W, then 220°C | 3 + 3 min, then 20 min | Waitrose |
| Air fryer | 200°C | About 45 min, turned halfway | ProCook |
| Microwave only | 900W (800W) | 6 min (7 min), plus 2 min standing | Tesco pack |
Ovens and potatoes both vary, so use these timings as a guide. The skewer has the final say.
Leftover jacket potatoes: storing and reheating
If you bake extra, take off any foil, let them cool and get them into the fridge within two hours, which is the Food Standards Agency’s rule for leftovers. University of California food-safety advisers add a caution about foil: botulism is rare, but outbreaks have been linked to potatoes baked in foil, so they advise taking the foil off as soon as the potatoes come out of the oven and storing them unwrapped. To reheat, the FSA’s test is simple: steaming hot all the way through. A cold baked potato also makes a good start to tomorrow’s hash or twice-baked jackets.
What to put in them
You don’t need a recipe for the filling. A few combinations worth knowing:
- Good butter and strong Cheddar, with salt and pepper and nothing else.
- Beans and cheese, upgraded. A cook in Waitrose’s guide adds a dash of Worcestershire sauce to the beans and uses crumbly Cheshire instead of Cheddar.
- Tuna mayo with sweetcorn and a squeeze of lemon. See the tuna jacket in our easy tuna recipes.
- Leftover chilli, with soured cream and chives.
- Cottage cheese and chives, or houmous with crumbled feta, for something lighter.
- Twice-baked: scoop out the flesh, mash it with butter and grated cheese, spoon it back into the skins and return them to the oven until golden.
Jacket potatoes also suit Bonfire Night: they are easy to hold in a gloved hand, and a slab of Yorkshire parkin makes a good pudding afterwards. And if roast potatoes are on the menu instead, our guide to the best potatoes for roasting covers the method that suits them.
Frequently asked questions
Which potatoes are best for jacket potatoes?
Floury potatoes. Maris Piper and King Edward are the classic choices, and a supermarket bag labelled “baking potatoes” is a sound budget buy, though the variety is rarely named. Vivaldi gives a creamier, richer jacket. Avoid waxy salad or new potatoes.
Are Maris Piper potatoes good for jacket potatoes?
Yes. Maris Piper has dry, floury flesh that bakes up fluffy, and Jamie Oliver’s team says it is often considered the gold standard for jacket potatoes in the UK. It is also widely sold by name.
Is King Edward or Maris Piper better for jacket potatoes?
Both are floury and both make excellent jackets, so there is little to choose between them. King Edward is the more traditional choice; Maris Piper is more widely sold by name. Buy whichever is fresher and better matched in size.
What potatoes are in a bag of baking potatoes?
Usually the bag doesn’t say, because the variety can change through the year. It may be a floury variety such as Maris Piper, or a variety grown for size such as Marfona, which the AHDB describes as a popular supermarket baker.
Are baking potatoes and jacket potatoes the same thing?
Yes. A jacket potato is a whole potato baked in its skin, and “baking potatoes” is the shop label for potatoes sized and selected for the job. You can bake any large floury potato as a jacket.
How long does a jacket potato take at 200°C?
About 1 hour to 1 hour 20 minutes for a large baking potato at 200°C (180°C fan, gas 6). Test with a skewer: it should slide through the middle with no resistance.
Should you wrap jacket potatoes in foil?
No, not if you want a crisp skin. Foil holds in moisture, and the skin needs to dry out to crisp. Bake the potato directly on the oven shelf with a little oil and salt rubbed into the skin. If you do use foil, remove it before storing any leftovers.
Can you reheat a jacket potato?
Yes. Cool it and refrigerate it within two hours of cooking, unwrapped, then reheat it until it is steaming hot all the way through, which is the Food Standards Agency’s test for reheated leftovers.
What is the UK equivalent of a russet potato?
Russet Burbank is the standard North American baking potato, with dry, mealy flesh. In the UK, use a floury variety such as Maris Piper or King Edward instead.
Sources
- BBC Gardeners’ World Magazine, “Best potatoes for baking” (2019 trial of ten varieties)
- AHDB British Potato Variety Database (entries for Marfona, Rooster and Maris Piper)
- Muller et al., “The Reliability of Dry Matter, Specific Gravity, Starch and Glycaemic Index to Classify Potatoes”, IntechOpen (2018)
- Murphy, True and Hogan, “Detection threshold of sensory panels for mealiness of baked potatoes”, American Potato Journal 44 (1967)
- Waitrose, “How to make the perfect jacket potato”
- Jamie Oliver, “For the love of… jacket potatoes”
- olive magazine, “Best jacket potato fillings ideas”
- Great British Chefs, potato variety guide
- Sainsbury’s Magazine, “Which potatoes should I use?”
- Food Standards Agency, acrylamide advice (potato storage and cooking colour)
- Food Standards Agency, reheating leftovers (steaming hot throughout)
- Food Standards Agency, “How to chill, freeze and defrost food safely” (leftovers in the fridge within two hours)
- University of California Master Food Preservers, “Baked potatoes” (foil and botulism)
- ProCook, air fryer jacket potato; Tesco Baking Potatoes 2kg (pack instructions); Sainsbury’s Taste the Difference Vivaldi Baking Potatoes; DT Brown, Cara seed potato; Albert Bartlett, Rooster
- Ripon Museums (King Edward, 1902); Wikipedia, “Russet Burbank”
Updated 12 October 2026 by Linda Garrould.





0 Comments